Tradition Hinders Progress

Tradition. I can practically hear the song from “Fiddler on the Roof” playing as people squawk at how the University and its football program has lost its sense of the word in recent years with the Dave Brandon era and subsequent mediocre football program that occurred during his reign. Fans proclaim that the want the tradition of the old days when football was simply about football without all of the gimmicks and high prices the program has seen lately. Yet, I highly doubt that they would be saying that if Michigan was behind in the times compared to other football powerhouses like Alabama and Ohio State. The game is now at the point where if a program isn’t up to these standards then they are considered to be behind.

A Place of Tradition

The recent firing of Michigan Head Coach Brady Hoke and the departure of athletic director Dave Brandon got me thinking about the concept of conservatism and how people like consistency but most of all, tradition. In recently reading the works of Irish conservative Edmund Burke, I was struck with his idea of how “a cobbler should stay at his task” i.e. stick with what you know and don’t change things. While I think that this idea is important to a degree, I also have to disagree with it. If we never change anything then we will be stuck in the past. Part of life is change.

People will always be disgruntled. People will always have something to complain about. That’s inevitable. When Rich Rodriguez was coaching people complained about him too. What I think is telling though of how the University will and must change is the statement made by Jim Hackett the other day. He said, “I want to get rid of the word Michigan Man.’” He was referencing what has become an iconic phrase harkening back to the days of Bo Schembechler, who used the term when describing how he wanted a candidate to be a coach at Michigan. However, people typically use it in reference to how someone has to be of the Michigan character and even have ties to Michigan. The problem with that, though is that we live in a world today where that just isn’t possible. The fans and the people who work for athletics need to adapt to the changing environment while also maintaining the integrity of the sport and the program that Michigan has always been so famous for.

Some Michigan Fans

I don’t think it is bad to assume that we should maintain an air of conservatism in the way our football program carries out business, but I also think it’s important to pay attention to the fact that the business game is always changing and sometimes we need to adapt to that. You can still maintain your core values while changing the way you do business.

3 thoughts on “Tradition Hinders Progress

  1. Out of curiosity, do you think that coaches should be changed every few years even if they are doing a good job? Or would you agree more with the phrase “if something isn’t broken, don’t fix it”? Take for instance Nick Saban at Alabama. He’s won 3 national titles in his tenure and has a shot to win another one this season. Whatever he’s doing is working. He has created his own tradition there. Is the problem at Michigan the fact that we aren’t quick enough to make changes when something isn’t working because we want tradition or is it that we haven’t found a guy who can establish his own tradition? Personally, I think it is the latter. With the right guy at the helm, we shouldn’t have to make too many changes in the future and we can go back to having the tradition of Michigan football.


  2. I really enjoyed reading your post! I agree with you that change can come about while still maintaining your core values. In live in such an evolving society and it is clear that we are slow to make certain changes due to tradition. Sports is a great way to show that slow progress in relation to society. I believe tradition does hinder progress, but should still be valued as well.


  3. Personally, when it comes to Michigan Football, I am a huge fan of tradition. I disagree with the changing of the big house, the addition of jumbotrons, playing music between plays, and publicizing the school like a name brand. One tradition I like in particular, however, is Michigan being a team that wins. As a result, I disagree with the Michigan Man, and I think we should put all focus on a new athletic director who likes tradition, and a new coach who likes winning.


Comments are closed.